Reviews for The Door That Never Was
| duj |
2018.12.22 - 06:45PM |
1: The Door That Never Was |
Signed |
| I see that other reviewers seem to think the drinker will wake up, but it's the Draught of Living Death; he'll sleep forever. (And it's necessary that he does. Presumably if he woke he could simply command the elves to release him...) |
| handpfeather |
2007.08.27 - 10:40PM |
1: The Door That Never Was |
Anonymous |
| Outstanding! I could walk with Snape every step of the way...Perfection.
Thanks |
| poivre |
2007.07.21 - 06:25AM |
1: The Door That Never Was |
Anonymous |
| Creepy and chilling. The last line was like a door into the kid's psyche. I liked that he just did his best to do what his mother asked and ended up with a better solution. Still the last line the numbness and amorality are shades of things to come. Great work. |
| Overhill |
2007.05.25 - 12:27PM |
1: The Door That Never Was |
Signed |
| I found this on the random generator, and have read it a number of times, and it always horrifies me! Good job on "The Cask of Amontillado" theme. I like how the house-elves came over to the other side. |
| Potioncat |
2006.08.19 - 02:28PM |
1: The Door That Never Was |
Signed |
| Oh, this woudl be a great Halloween story. I'm glad I read it before I saw your own comment about Poe--Poe jumped out and yellled "Cask of Amontillado" about one or two lines before the end. I didn't catch on at all as the story developed. Very nice work. |
| slytherin05 |
2005.07.25 - 07:16PM |
1: The Door That Never Was |
Signed |
| wow! go snape!! i love snape despite what happens, he's a great character and incredibly interesting! |
| Semne |
2005.07.12 - 10:36PM |
1: The Door That Never Was |
Anonymous |
| Kudos to you. This was really good. |
| OperaRose |
2005.07.05 - 11:57AM |
1: The Door That Never Was |
Signed |
| Oooooooh, such a great story! One of the best one shots I've read (and that's saying alot!). |
| Rickmansfix |
2005.07.04 - 06:04PM |
1: The Door That Never Was |
Anonymous |
| Whoa! Remind me not to mess with him, right? Excellent chapter. I loved the way you let this twist just a bit. Brilliant.
|
| el laura |
2005.07.04 - 09:25AM |
1: The Door That Never Was |
Anonymous |
Nice tale! I like the implication that Snape was thinking about his own childhood talking to Harry.
Author's Response: Hi el laura! Thank you so much! Glad you enjoyed it. |
[Previous] 1 2 [Next]
|