Home | Members | Help | Submission Rules | Log In |
Recently Added | Categories | Titles | Completed Fics | Random Fic | Search | Top Fictions

Reviews for In Memory of Severus Snape

duj 2014.07.07 - 01:30AM 1: In Memory of Severus Snape Signed
Of course, a Gryffindor would think that "brave" is the highest compliment one can give. I have a higher, which I'd give to no other adult in the Potterverse: he was a person of integrity.

AnarioM 2012.09.01 - 09:20PM 1: In Memory of Severus Snape Signed
Wonderful and simply put....you really captured my two favorite characters in a porfoudly real manner. Bravo!

loreen77 2012.08.05 - 11:42AM 1: In Memory of Severus Snape Signed
Lovely, beautifully done.

Author's Response: Thank you, glad you liked it! :-)

hexgirl 2012.02.03 - 07:55AM 1: In Memory of Severus Snape Signed
How did I miss this? This was beautifully done, Herbologist. I always felt that Minerva would take the revelation of his true loyalty badly: I think any true Gryffindor would because he showed himself to be honourable, brave and true - the very qualities they consider so valuable. I love the reference you made to the fact that he appeared at peace and that she wondered what his last thought had been, it's a comforting idea to hope that his last moments were peaceful. This genuinely brought a tear to my eye. Very well done as always. :)

Author's Response: Hi hexgirl, thanks so much for lovely review! I like to think he passed away at peace, looking into his Lily's eyes, and able to look her in the eye once more after all he did to redeem himself.

Oracle of moon 2012.01.16 - 09:18AM 1: In Memory of Severus Snape Signed
"I was hoping it would end with Severus reading the tribute (i.e. alive). I'm convinced that is the reason his portrait is missing." (x2) I completely agree with her! This was one of the most beautiful tributes I´ve read. Did you pass all the characteristics of Minerva great well! I also have a fanfic centered on Minerva and Severus (she saves him =D), but reading yours, I felt I could have described it much better, congratulations! In fact, I would love to translate it to post on brazilian´s fanfic sites (yes, I'm brazilian). Would you let me translate this tribute? (with all due credit to you of course!)

Author's Response: Thanks so much for your wonderful review. Of course you may translate this and post on brazilian fanfic sites. I would feel really honoured.

peskipiksi 2012.01.16 - 08:54AM 1: In Memory of Severus Snape Signed
Just beautiful. Wish I'd written it :)

Author's Response: Thank you, that's a wonderful compliment :-)

Sariana 2012.01.06 - 12:32AM 1: In Memory of Severus Snape Signed
Lovely tribute. I was hoping it would end with Severus reading the tribute (i.e. alive). I'm convinced that is the reason his portrait is missing. ; )

Author's Response: Ah, sorry, it was part of the challenge for him to be really dead! But in my other stories he does live, so I do agree with you that this is the real reason for the portrait missing. :-)

lie 2011.11.25 - 05:10PM 1: In Memory of Severus Snape Signed
wonderful, its perfect

Author's Response: Thank you!

June W 2011.11.14 - 03:20AM 1: In Memory of Severus Snape Signed
Beautifully done, Minerva! (kicks Dumbledore's portrait... useless thing...)

Author's Response: Haha, indeed... He stops meddling the moment she would actually appreciate his help! Thanks for reading and reviewing!

Rose of the West 2011.11.13 - 08:22PM 1: In Memory of Severus Snape Signed
What a lovely tribute! I admit to a small chuckle about how she procrastinated until the last day, since so many of us did that who wrote for this challenge. Even so, I think you well captured how she must have felt, after realizing just how wrong she was.

Author's Response: Thank you so much, Rose! I have to admit to being a bit of a procrastinator myself sometimes... She must have felt awful, and so glad she didn't manage to kill him!

[Previous] 1 2 [Next]


Disclaimers
Terms of Use
Credits

Copyright © 2003-2007 Sycophant Hex
All rights reserved