Reviews for What Snape Wants
| yymyyzt |
2019.02.01 - 09:49AM |
1: What Snape Wants |
Signed |
| Thank you for letting me know about your decision.
I feel bad to know Occlumency is not popular in nowadays as I found so many good stories here. Many of them are truly deserved more people to read, just like yours. I really enjoyed reading and rereading your work. I'm disappointed that I won't be able to translate this wonderful story. I have to confess that I am just a volunteer who have never received professional translation training. Translation is my hobby because I feel great to share those brilliant stories I loved without borders. And without any doubt, I never intended to get the credit for any of the stories I translated, those are the properties of the individual writers.
Sorry for being lengthy. Thanks for sharing your stories. Wish you all the best. |
| yymyyzt |
2019.01.11 - 11:01PM |
1: What Snape Wants |
Signed |
Thank you for writing this beautiful work! Absolutely amazing!
I believe your work deserved more people to read. I would like to ask your permission to translate this.
I value your feedback, so please let me know what you think. ;)
Author's Response: Hi. Thanks for the feedback. No one has been on here for so long that it was quite a treat. However, I think I would rather you did not translate it. |
| hot_stuff11 |
2014.05.24 - 06:16PM |
1: What Snape Wants |
Signed |
| Absolutely amazing. Deep and powerful and moving! |
| anthat |
2012.08.16 - 12:47AM |
1: What Snape Wants |
Signed |
| Well done. Charachter depth with out becoming sappy or cliche. |
| Snapesbeatrice |
2010.04.01 - 11:49PM |
1: What Snape Wants |
Signed |
| Your story was a mix of creepiness and heart-felt caring. Very well done. |
| Maria |
2010.03.09 - 09:00PM |
1: What Snape Wants |
Signed |
| I looked for this story in my favourites just a few days ago and just about *freaked* when it wasn't there!!!!!!!!! Sooooooo glad I visited digital-quill today and found this again!!! This remains the most poignant and canon-compliant Snape fanfic ever written, in my opinion. Even back when you first posted this, I knew something about it rang true - and when I at last finished reading DH, I came back to your story immediately because I remembered it so well. Thank you, thank you, for putting this here again! |
| Herbologist |
2010.03.09 - 05:25PM |
1: What Snape Wants |
Signed |
| Very sad, and very moving at the same time. The one thing Severus really needs, he can never have. |
| hexgirl |
2010.03.07 - 04:37AM |
1: What Snape Wants |
Signed |
| This would work beautifully as a poignant, heartbreaking stand alone, but I can't say I'm not glad that there is going to be more. Experiencing Snape from a Muggle woman's point of view makes the reader really empathise with her. There is a sense of realism which is often not felt in HP based fanfics because of the magical element, obviously. But encountering Snape through the eyes of a Muggle makes the whole thing so alive; I actually felt like he could exist in that little grimy house in Spiner's End. You certainly haven't Rickmanised Snape, which again made him feel so very canon for me. The part where he becomes almost shy when she takes on Lily's appearance was truly moving, and at the end when she forgives him I was bereft. I love your writing style, you drew me in from the first sentence and I just couldn't stop reading. In short - Wow! this is a bar raiser. |
| Severus49 |
2010.03.05 - 10:54PM |
1: What Snape Wants |
Signed |
| Not enough adjectives to describe it. Tragic, sad, heartbreaking - that gets close. |
| Stella Stargazer |
2010.03.04 - 09:43AM |
1: What Snape Wants |
Signed |
| I am sure I have read this beautiful story before, but I certainly appreciate the opportunity to read it again. I will be looking for updates as well. I really cannot guess where you will take us with this. |
[Previous] 1 2 [Next]
|