Home | Members | Help | Submission Rules | Log In |
Recently Added | Categories | Titles | Completed Fics | Random Fic | Search | Top Fictions

Reviews for Making Amends

MithLuin 2007.10.12 - 06:02PM 1: Making Amends Anonymous
This was great! I like Snape's idea, and if he ever regrets it, he can take his revenge out on Lupin by feeding him all sorts of nasty potions ;).

phoenix 2005.04.23 - 08:02PM 1: Making Amends Signed
Very nicely done. I think you really captured Snape well. I love the karma was conspiring against him, forcing him to atone for being mean. And the letter was perfectly worded for Snape. :)

sophierom 2005.01.06 - 05:04PM 1: Making Amends Signed
Wow, what a great fic! Wonderful back story for Snape, who is appropriately crafty and ambitious. I also think the fic works well with canon - helps explain why we didn't see Lupin throughout GoF. Are you JKR in disguise? :-) Thanks for the story; I really enjoyed it. Best, Sophie

Author's Response: Glad you liked the story. Sadly, I'm definitely not JKR. I'm American and much less wealthy than she! But I'm glad I was able to emulate her style :)

droxy 2005.01.02 - 09:31PM 1: Making Amends Anonymous
Nicely crafted story that fits with canon. But I wouldn't call it snupin (slash), they don't even kiss. Interesting how you got the slytherin to work out his charity issues, it would not suprise me in the least if someone (hint) was effecting SS dreams.

Author's Response: No, I wouldn't call it Snupin or slash either. It's definitely a gen fic, with the possiblity of being more eventually. Depends on if I come up with a storyline :)

winna 2005.01.02 - 01:19PM 1: Making Amends Signed
I'm not a fan of Snape/Lupin, but I did like this story. The details were what I liked best, like a Snape raised in poverty and the jab at Lupin's silly mustache. I would read a sequel, if you wrote one...

June W 2004.12.31 - 11:15PM 1: Making Amends Signed
Hmmm, I just wonder who's paying Lupin's salary - did Severus finagle the money from the Hogwarts budget, or....? Thanks for the story!

Author's Response: The way I figured it, a Hogwarts teacher really has no need to spend much of their salary as their room and board is paid. So my view is that Snape has been hoarding his salary for the most part, and thus can afford to give half of it (or more) to Lupin to assuage his guilt feelings :)

Squill 2004.12.31 - 11:14PM 1: Making Amends Signed
Very believable story, and well written too. Thank you for sharing!

LariLee 2004.12.31 - 10:06PM 1: Making Amends Signed
It's a marvelous way to help someone without being weak. And saves pride on both sides! Wonderfully done,

Terms of Use

Copyright 2003-2007 Sycophant Hex
All rights reserved